Apr 20,2010
I notice that BBC Radio 4 announcers regularly pronounce Ms O’Leary’s family name as /əʊˈlɛəri/. I suppose from her accent that this is what she calls herself, but I’m wondering if following suit when one does not have an Irish accent is mimicking her rather than representing her name in ‘neutral’ terms. For those unfamiliar with Radio 4’s output, Olivia O’Leary is the presenter of “Between Ourselves”, a discussion programme that deals with a single issue in each edition.
To start from a different example. True to my roots, I pronounce bath with the TRAP vowel (as John Wells says in Accents of English, it would seem a denial of my northernness to change this). A friend of mine comes from the City of Bath, and he insists that I am mispronouncing his city. On the other hand, he pronounces Newcastle with the same BATH vowel (not a good key word in this discussion!), regardless of the fact that most Novocastrians from either Newcastle upon Tyne or Newcastle under Lyme will use the TRAP vowel. In my view, he is right to say /…’kɑːsl/ and I am right to say /bæθ/ – both in the terms of our own accents.
To return to Ms O’Leary. In her accent, I assume she calls King Lear /lɛər/. Certainly, when the Short Brothers Lear Fan Jet plane was in the news, Northern Irish commentators called it the /lɛər fɑːn/, but this did not persuade others to pronounce it in the same way. In my view, Ms O’Leary should be pronounced /əʊˈlɪəri/ by the announcers from other parts of the UK. By trying too hard to get a close approximation to her own pronunciation, they might appear to be simply making fun of it (and by extension, her).
Archives
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
Links
Recent Posts
- Bulger
- Pronunciation mayhem?
- Unclear English
- The Queen’s English Society
- A taliswoman, and how to remediate
- Paradisical vestiges
- Latin and English – again
- Olivia O’Leary
- Waverley
- Spanish rhythm
- Homing in
- Cognitive
- Bleck Het
- Moshtarak
- Wymondham (Norfolk) and Wymondley (Hertfordshire)
Recent Comments
- Chris Hebbron on Abergavenny, etc
- Sanford S. Silverman on English spelling reform
- Duncan Hill on Abergavenny, etc
- Eric Hayman on The Queen’s English Society
- Eric Hayman on The Queen’s English Society
- Alec Bamford on Uttoxeter
- Masha Bell on The Queen’s English Society
- Noel on English spelling reform
- Graham on The Queen’s English Society
- The Queen’s English Society deplores your impurities « Sentence first on The Queen’s English Society
- Martin Ball on The Queen’s English Society
- dw on The Queen’s English Society
- Mark Poxon on The Oxford BBC Guide to Pronunciation
- Mark Poxon on More on BBC Pronunciation
- Remd on French linguistic politics
4 Responses for "Olivia O’Leary"
Interesting thought.
I wonder how much this perception – of people makng fun rather than being neutral – might extend to consciously faithful pronunciations of foreign words and place names, where such pronunciations diverge from the standard Anglicized form.
In my native (staunchly monolingual English-speaking) region of Canada, for example, using an “box” vowel [ɑ] (cardinal 5) rather than an “at” vowel [æ] when saying “Iran” or “Iraq” would come across as pretentious. This is despite the fact that the “box” vowel is more faithful to the native pronunciation of these words, and completely compatible with English phonotactics.
Pronunciations that violate English phonotactics come off as even more pretentious. For example, paying attention to quantity distinctions in Italian consonants. (To be fair, I only remember seeing this in a movie, spoken by a very pretentious character.)
Many British people pronounce the first name of the President of the United States as /ˈbærək/ instead of Mr Obama’s preferred /bəˈrɑːk/
This is despite the fact that there is no phonotactic reason why /bəˈrɑːk/ should be forbidden: indeed “Iraq” is widely pronounced /ɪˈrɑːk/ in Southern England.
There is an interesting discussion of this at the Separated By A Common Language blog.
Unless Ms O’Leary’s pronunciation has changed radically since she was on Irish TV back when I lived there, I expect she pronounces her name much as I do, which is to say /oʊˈlɪːri/. Some regional Irish accents would indeed pronounce her name with an /ɛ/ vowel but neither hers nor mine is one of them. (She is from Carlow and I am from Dublin.) So the BBC announcers’ rendition is doubly strange.
I listened to the beginning and end of several of her broadcasts available on the net, hoping to catch her in the act of pronouncing her own name, but to no avail.
So did I. Pathetic, aren’t we? But I had made the same assumptions as you. I can only think that the names of the presenter and the jet plane are examples of both Southern and Northern Irish ɪːr being perceived as ɛər by mainland Brits in the BBC because in the context of –r it does not have the close i they expect in Irish accents.
I guess we all agree that such mimicry between accents of English is absurd, especially incompetent mimicry, but surely varying degrees of approximation to a realistic pronunciation of non-naturalized words and names in other languages can be appropriate in varying circumstances.
But even non-mimicry can seem extreme to people who disapprove of Brits of any sort. I cannot resist contributing an anecdote of my own. I was berated by a friend for calling him hju:ɪ (not his real name) məkˈmɑːn (he could do a parodic RP), and told in no uncertain terms that his name was kjʉi makʲˈmaχən. I said I would attempt that if he would desist from calling me ˈmɛɪχəl lɑːm. This arrangement soon lapsed.
Leave a reply